Kategóriavita:Nápoly és Szicília királynéi

Legutóbb hozzászólt Peadar 13 évvel ezelőtt a(z) Interwiki témában

Interwiki szerkesztés

Please do not add wrong interwikis. Now they are mixed up: Czech means just "queens", Italian "Royal consorts of the Two Sicilies", Polish "Italian queens", English "Italian queens consort" (wifes of kings, not queens in a fact). You have wrong Commons link as well (to "queens"). As you have already Kategória:Olasz királynék connected to en:Category:Italian queens consort, you should connect this category to en:Category:Royal consorts of Sicily or en:Category:Royal consorts of Naples. – Czech Wikipedian Gumruch vita 2010. augusztus 13., 22:19 (CEST)Válasz

Megbeszélés itt / Discussion here: Wikipédia:Kategóriajavaslatok/Archív21#Nápolyi, szicíliai és nápoy-szicíliai királynék (EnWiki észrevétele). Akela vita 2010. augusztus 13., 23:11 (CEST)Válasz

Of course, Gumruch is not right, because in Hungarian there is only one category for queens consorts of Sicily and Naples because Sicily and Naples have been considered historically as only state, so this category gathers all the queens consorts and therefore one had to seek for a similar category among the interwiki but this task has failed because only in the Hungarian wiki operates a united category for the queens consorts of Sicily and Naples, and one had to find a good solution, so e.g. en:Category:Italian queens consort was chosen for the best possibility to connect en:Category:Royal consorts of Sicily with en:Category:Royal consorts of Naples, so Gumruch is not right to urge hunwiki to choose between the two categories because if you enter en:Category:Italian queens consort, you can find either en:Category:Royal consorts of Sicily or en:Category:Royal consorts of Naples but if you connect hu:Kategória:Nápoly és Szicília királynéi, either to en:Category:Royal consorts of Sicily or to en:Category:Royal consorts of Naples, it will be difficult and it will go false to find the other queens consorts and in huwiki there ain't category for "Italian queens consorts", so you cannot go to wrong direction.Peadar vita 2010. augusztus 14., 03:03 (CEST)Válasz

Visszatérés a(z) „Nápoly és Szicília királynéi” laphoz.